St Paul's Institute

[Summary Report] The City and the Common Good: What kind of City do we want?

by St Pauls Institute

Posted: 11 Oct 2013

In the first half of this year St Paul's Institute, in conjunction with CCLA, presented a series of three free public events with associated seminars entitled The City and the Common Good: What kind of City do we want?

Held under the dome of St Paul's Cathedral and chaired by Stephanie Flanders, all three events tackled issues at the heart of the financial crisis.  The seminars that ran alongside the main events explored professional issues in more detail.

A summary report of the series has now been released, highlighting key points made by the eminent speakers who contributed to the series; including keynote presentations from Archbishop Vincent Nichols, Lord Skidelsky and Archbishop Justin Welby.


To coincide with the release of this report, those who registered to attend the series were asked to complete a survey expressing their views on the topics discussed and the question: What kind of City do we want?

Of the 284 respondents, a quarter of whom currently work in the City, 91% agreed that we need to 'define more clearly the social purpose of the finance sector' with the largest percentage (38%) also indicating that'maximum profit as motivation'was one of the primary causes of negative behaviour and results in the City today.

There was clear agreement (65%) that we should 'protect the UK's global standing as a centre of finance' but 66% disagree with the idea that we might 'allow market forces to self-correct without intervention' as three quarters of respondents preferred to support a cap on bonuses (72%) alongside punitive measures to 'ensure individuals responsible for failures face criminal charges' (76%).

The results of the survey provide a clear indication that much work still needs be done in order to repair the damage to society caused by the current financial system. Significant clarifications and changes will be imperative if public trust in the City is ever to be restored.

The Revd Canon Mark Oakley, Chancellor of St Paul's Cathedral, said: "This series has made it clear that calling this a "financial crisis" is misleading. It is a human crisis. Seeing values devalued, our question was not 'when will the crisis end?' but 'what do we need to learn from this? What kind of City do we want to build?' A clear majority voice the need to reclaim the social purpose of the City, believing human flourishing is more than just survival or profit."

Michael Quicke OBE, Chief Executive of CCLA said: "The system we have is finding it difficult to reform itself, and this series of debates has proved a valuable forum for the examination of the link between morals and markets. There is no silver bullet to deal with the problems, but if the City is to be reformed, banks must put the interests of their customers above those of their shareholders in order to rebuild trust and restore the relationship between financial services and society as a whole."

About this author

St Paul's Institute seeks to foster an informed Christian response to the most urgent ethical and spiritual issues of our times: equality, stewardship, and the meaning of the common good.

Comment on this dialogue


The opinions expressed in this article are those of the author, and do not necessarily represent the views of St Paul's Institute or St Paul's Cathedral.